in programming

Knuth hates XP

In this recent interview, Donald Knuth says:

“Still, I hate to duck your questions even though I also hate to offend other people’s sensibilities—given that software methodology has always been akin to religion. With the caveat that there’s no reason anybody should care about the opinions of a computer scientist/mathematician like me regarding software development, let me just say that almost everything I’ve ever heard associated with the term “extreme programming” sounds like exactly the wrong way to go…with one exception. The exception is the idea of working in teams and reading each other’s code. That idea is crucial, and it might even mask out all the terrible aspects of extreme programming that alarm me.

I also must confess to a strong bias against the fashion for reusable code. To me, “re-editable code” is much, much better than an untouchable black box or toolkit. I could go on and on about this. If you’re totally convinced that reusable code is wonderful, I probably won’t be able to sway you anyway, but you’ll never convince me that reusable code isn’t mostly a menace.”

There are only a few people who can get away with saying that and actually have people listen to them – and Knuth is definitely one of them. I would love to hear him expand on the “terrible aspects of extreme programming.” If he had an email address I would ask him about it, but unfortunately he doesn’t.

Write a Comment

Comment